This summer I started researching hoarding disorder, and it illuminated a lot of things.
I have been accused of hoarding (at least half-jokingly) since I was a child. I have always been a 'pack rat.' I have always carried either a backpack or a very large bag everywhere I go. I go through it and clean stuff out regularly for the sake of my back, but I have just always carried around a lot of stuff. You never know when you're going to need a pair of scissors, or spare AA batteries, or a protein bar, or sunglasses.
My room was always in a state of (somewhat) organized chaos. All the papers were loose, but they were all in one pile. Half the clothes weren't on hangers, but they were all piled on the same chair. I could still see the floor, and I vacuumed the ever-shrinking patch fairly regularly. I had a trash can, and I emptied it whenever it was full. I took dirty dishes up to the dishwasher within 24 hours at least (but usually the same day). My parents and siblings knew not to touch anything in that room lest I spiral into a full-blown panic attack about the 'missing' (usually just moved) object. I could find everything I needed.
A few months ago, during some argument, my husband accused me of being a hoarder. I fired back that I wasn't half as messy as I used to be (which is true), but the words lodged in my brain.
What if I really am a hoarder?
I started Googling.
My fear was quickly put to rest as I saw the pictures of what true hoarding looked like. Our house was messy, but it was nothing like those photos. We still had surfaces on which to sit, and cook, and do projects. We still had clean, usable floor space.
But some of those photos did look familiar. The cardboard boxes stacked high, the empty margarine containers on every available surface, the newspapers piled in corners. That -- that was my grandparents' house.
My paternal grandparents' house had always felt small and cramped. I was well into my teens before I realised that their 'tiny' basement was supposed to have a fireplace on one wall -- that's why I could see brick at the top, behind all the cardboard boxes that slowly encroached on the discoloured patch of shag carpet, the old once-blue exercise bike, and the ragged and very out-of-tune piano. I watched, in real time, as the old spare room in the basement that we played in as kids became so full of boxes and old clothes that we couldn't play there anymore. Then the upstairs spare room that we played in after that suffered the same fate. There was apparently a second spare room in the basement that I have never seen because there were so many boxes piled in front of it from before the time I was old enough to climb down the stairs. I distinctly remember the moment I realised that one of the piles in the basement was actually on a large wooden workbench, and I only realised this because I suddenly recognised a wooden table leg amid the visual chaos. The surface was completely gone. Among the clutter, there was a used, vintage KFC chicken bucket. I know it was used because there were grease stains on it. I examined it once and saw a copyright date of 1973.
I remember at some point in my childhood asking my parents why my grandparents had so much stuff. My parents explained that they had grown up during the Great Depression and World War II and were so used to having to save everything, just in case, that they hadn't learned how to turn off the instinct. That was enough explanation for me. I didn't connect the dots between my grandparents' house and the phenomenon of 'hoarding' until this year, despite years of their children (my parents, aunts, and uncles) trying to intervene and often congregating to clean out the garage or the basement or the backyard. My grandmother would 'give things away' to the kids, knowing full well the things would get thrown out, but unable to placate my grandfather about it any other way.
The more I think about that house, the more I realise how mid-century glamourous it really was. It has a HUGE kitchen (literally bigger than the entire apartment my husband and I just moved from), at least four, maybe five bedrooms, a large basement with a massive storage room and (presumably?) a faux fireplace, a basement exit, 2.5 bathrooms, a large walkout balcony from the master bedroom (which itself took up over half the upstairs), with a sunroom underneath and a huge backyard. If you were to build and sell a house today with that exact floor plan, it would be worth well over half a million dollars. They were sitting on an absolute jewel of a house, but my memories of it are that everything was tainted. I always felt somehow contaminated every time I set foot in there and I never really thought about why. I just knew I didn't like going there. Something about their house always made my skin crawl.
Then I remembered the one time I was in my one aunt's house, how stuffed bears and craft supplies covered every available surface. I mean every surface. There weren't even any chairs to sit on because they were all covered in stuffed animals. How when my oldest uncle died of cancer, it took weeks for the entire neighbourhood to help his wife clean up the yard. How my youngest uncle and his then-wife were constantly at odds about all the engine parts in their yard. How my own dad only has goat paths through his huge workshop, despite my (more motivated) siblings cleaning it out at least once a year since I moved out.
Then I began to understand my husband's fear. I am nowhere near that level yet, but all the genetics are there, he knows I grew up poor, he knows I have a significant variety of trauma in my personal history, he knows I struggle a lot with boring things like organization and cleaning.
Meds have helped me with motivation and I also notice meds make it easier to get rid of things. But I don't know if there's a way to get rid of the genetic fear of going without that has been built into my soul one cardboard box at a time for three decades.